Stuffed Hot Peppers (Baked not Fried)

Jump to Recipe Print Recipe

Disclosure: this article contains an affiliate link. As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases, at no cost to you.

In this article
  1. What Type of Hot Peppers Should I Use?
  2. How to Make Stuffed Hot Peppers (Baked Not Fried)
  3. Tips/Recipe Notes
  4. Check Out These Other Delicious Appetizers

Stuffed hot peppers (baked not fried) are far from the greasy bar food of your memories, but with all the flavor! Great to spice up an everyday meal or add to your next party spread. Use up those summer peppers at their peak.

Baked stuffed hot peppers on a white plate and on parchment paper, with fresh peppers on a gray wooden table

So why are these stuffed hot peppers such a great appetizer? Delicious, of course, but also healthier and less messy than fried gooey poppers. You will love the creamy filling topped with crunchy panko crumbs and a zesty finish. They are small in size but really big on taste!

Three baked stuffed hot peppers with a golden crumb topping on parchment paper

What Type of Hot Peppers Should I Use?

Any type of pepper will work with my recipe. It all depends on how hot you like your food. Traditional jalapeños or Hungarian wax are common but I often use peppers with less heat.

My family likes mild to medium heat so I generally use mariachi, poblano or Anaheim peppers. I have even made these appetizers with peppers that are not hot at all, such as cubanelle, and added a little more spice to my filling. A helpful hint is to use a variety of peppers so you can please everyone’s taste buds.

If researching a new pepper to try, check out the Scoville scale which measures the heat of the pepper. Each variety has a different concentration of capsaicin. The higher the number, the hotter the pepper. Peppers with the most heat can go up to 16,000,000 on the scale! Here is a great chart to see the Scoville heat level of peppers from Chili Pepper Madness.

How to Make Stuffed Hot Peppers (Baked Not Fried)

Six step photos showing how to fill, top and bake stuffed hot peppers

Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

Slit hot peppers with triangular cuts to allow for easy filling. Remove seeds and membrane.

Add cream cheese, cheddar cheese, garlic powder, chipotle powder, cumin and lime juice to food processor and mix well.

Fill hot peppers with mixture even to top of pepper.

In a medium bowl, mix the egg with the bread crumbs until well blended. Spoon on top of peppers. Press crumbs lightly to stick to cheese filling.

Place peppers cut side up on cookie sheet with parchment paper or silicone non-stick baking mat. Pour a small amount of olive oil on each pepper before baking.

Bake for 30 minutes or until golden brown.

Tips/Recipe Notes

  • I use mild and medium heat peppers but you can use hot depending on your taste.
  • If using hot peppers, be careful to remove all the seeds. Much of the heat of the pepper is in the seed so you will increase the spiciness if all seeds are not removed.
  • I cut a triangular shape on my peppers for easy filling.
  • I strongly recommend using gloves when working with hot peppers. The capsaicin in the peppers gives them their spicy hot flavor, but can cause a burning sensation if the peppers come in contact with your skin, especially the face and eyes.
  • Stuffed hot peppers can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 5 days or frozen for 3 months.

Baked stuffed hot peppers with a crispy crumb topping on a metal baking sheet

Check Out These Other Delicious Appetizers

Vegetarian Stuffed Mushrooms

Deviled Eggs

Savory Scones with Asparagus

Shared at Weekend Potluck.

Stuffed Hot Peppers (Baked not Fried)

Stuffed Hot Peppers (Baked not Fried)

5 from 3 votes

Stuffed hot peppers (baked not fried) are far from the greasy bar food of your memories, but with all the flavor! Great to spice up an everyday meal or add to your next party spread. Use up those summer peppers at their peak.

Print Recipe

Prep Time
20 mins
Cook Time
30 mins
Course
Appetizer, Sides
Cuisine
Homestyle, Vegetarian
Servings
10 peppers

Ingredients

Instructions

  1. Preheat oven to 350 degrees.

  2. Slit hot peppers with triangular cuts to allow for easy filling. Remove seeds and membrane.

  3. Add cream cheese, cheddar cheese, garlic powder, chipotle powder, cumin and lime juice to food processor and mix well.

  4. Fill hot peppers with mixture even to top of pepper.

  5. In a medium bowl, mix the egg with the bread crumbs until well blended. Spoon on top of peppers. Press crumbs lightly to stick to cheese filling.

  6. Place peppers cut side up on cookie sheet with parchment paper or silicone non-stick baking mat. Pour a small amount of olive oil on each pepper before baking.

  7. Bake for 30 minutes or until golden brown.

Notes

I use mild and medium heat peppers but you can use hot depending on your taste.


If using hot peppers, be careful to remove all the seeds. Much of the heat of the pepper is in the seed so you will increase the spiciness if all seeds are not removed.


I cut a triangular shape on my peppers for easy filling. 

I strongly recommend using gloves when working with hot peppers. The capsaicin in the peppers gives them their spicy hot flavor, but can cause a burning sensation if the peppers come in contact with your skin, especially the face and eyes.


Stuffed hot peppers can be stored in the refrigerator for up to 5 days or frozen for 3 months.


Nutrition

Calories: 124 kcalCarbohydrates: 11 gProtein: 6 gFat: 7 gSaturated Fat: 4 gCholesterol: 39 mgSodium: 161 mgPotassium: 187 mgFiber: 1 gSugar: 3 gVitamin A: 663 IUVitamin C: 66 mgCalcium: 111 mgIron: 1 mg

Annie

12Comments

  1. Jutta Kowalenko

    I’ll just fill the peppers from the mixture right from the processor instead of transferring into a bowl. and save cleaning time. I can’t wait to try it.

  2. Jhuls | The Not So Creative Cook

    These are one of the perfect party foods!! Thanks for sharing at Fiesta Friday party!!😍

  3. Deborah Brooks

    I am a huge fan of jalapeño and love the poppers!These look easy and delicious thanks so much for linking up w us for meatless Monday today

  4. patrick@looneyforfood.com

    What a great party food!

  5. Sarah

    Huge fan of stuffed peppers and I have LOTS of peppers to use up in the garden. I’ve been giving away grocery bags full we have so many. I’ll have to go pick some and make these for Monday night football.

  6. Haoyu

    ★★★★★


    I am a Chinese student studying in US now, it is always a great fun for me to cook and try some American or Western food. I have cooked this “stuffed peppers” several times just following the recipe. Have to say it is pretty easy one even though I cooked Chinese style most time. About taste, delicious and crispy, perfect for appetizer, or game party snacks. And I like to use peppers of various spicy level, making the taste more “unpredictable”.

  7. Kjofct

    ★★★★★


    These are absolutely addictive! Especially yummy with peppers fresh from the farm or garden.

  8. Patty Schieder

    ★★★★★


    Cheers to pestoforpennies! We made this recipe in our air fryer and it turned out delicious! The cheese topping turned golden brown and the texture of the peppers was perfect. We make it now a couple times a week and love every bite! Thanks for having such a lovely website!

    1. Ann Neumann

      Using an air fryer is a great idea! I plan on trying it this week (when I finally get my first air fryer)!

  9. Ray

    Do you cook before freezing?

    1. Ann Neumann

      Yes, I cook before freezing. They reheat perfectly after being frozen. Make sure to defrost before reheating.

  10. Lori

    Looking for side dish for when I make them for my hunter boyfriend as a meal.

Comments are closed.